In this episode, the male superheroes are kidnapped and forced to fight against each other to find who the champion is.

Aqualad and Speedy are paired off against each other. With his control of the seas, Aqualad has the early advantage and almost drowns Speedy. However, quick use of an arrow that freezes water not only traps Aqualad in a wall of ice, but because he was covered in water himself, turns the hero into an ice statue, frozed in place.